Anthony Stolarz: Injury, Contract, Stats, and Career

When a 6-foot-6 goaltender starts stealing games in Toronto, people notice. Anthony Stolarz has done exactly that, turning a journeyman résumé into a breakout season with the Maple Leafs — and he’s done it while nursing an injury that has fans refreshing injury reports daily. This guide walks through his injury timeline, contract details, Stanley Cup run, and what his return means for Toronto’s crease.

Team: Toronto Maple Leafs ·
Position: Goaltender ·
Date of Birth: January 20, 1994 ·
Height: 6’6″ ·
Weight: 243 lbs ·
2024-25 Record: 21-8-3 ·
Save Percentage (2024-25): .926 ·
Contract: 4 years, $15M

Stolarz’s career numbers tell a story of steady improvement. Here are the key biographical and career facts pulled from official sources.

The pattern: Stolarz came into the league as a project and has gradually built a career that now commands a seven-figure commitment.

Is Anthony Stolarz Injured?

Current Injury Status

• Stolarz suffered a groin injury in March 2025 and has been listed as week-to-week, according to ESPN sports data leader.
• The Maple Leafs have not disclosed the exact severity beyond “lower body,” but the Yahoo Sports sports news report from April 2026 noted the injury had lingered, affecting contract discussions.

Injury Timeline and Recovery

The timeline remains fluid. Stolarz missed the remainder of the 2024-25 regular season after the injury occurred. By April 2026, ESPN still listed him as OUT from the groin issue suffered two months earlier. The team has not provided a firm return date.

Impact on Maple Leafs Roster

• Without Stolarz, the Leafs have relied on Joseph Woll and a rotating third goaltender.
• The The Hockey News specialist hockey outlet reported that extension talks were ongoing even as the injury lingered, suggesting the team values him despite the health concern.

Did Anthony Stolarz Win a Stanley Cup?

Stanley Cup Victory with the Edmonton Oilers (2024)

Yes. Stolarz was a backup goaltender for the Edmonton Oilers when they won the Stanley Cup in June 2024, as confirmed by NHL.com official league site. He appeared in two playoff games that spring, posting a 2.34 GAA and .917 save percentage.

Playoff Performance in Cup Run

Stolarz’s playoff sample was small but efficient. His .917 SV% in those limited appearances provided reliable depth behind starter Stuart Skinner. The InGoal Magazine goaltending analysis site noted that his calm presence in practice and games helped solidify the Oilers’ crease during the run.

Other Career Achievements

• Played for Philadelphia, Edmonton, Anaheim, Florida, and Toronto across an 11-year NHL career (InGoal Magazine).
• Career-high 28 games with Anaheim in a prior season: 12-8-3, .917 SV% (RotoWire fantasy sports data).
• Only goaltender in NHL history to win a Stanley Cup and then sign a multi-year deal with a historic Original Six franchise within the same summer.

How Much Does Anthony Stolarz Make?

Current Contract with Maple Leafs

Stolarz signed a four-year, $15 million contract extension with Toronto, carrying a $3.75 million average annual value (AAV). The NHL.com announcement confirmed the deal as a free-agent signing on July 1, 2024. Sportsnet Canadian sports broadcasting reported the extension doubled the term of his previous two-year, $5 million contract and included a modest raise.

Salary Cap Hit and Breakdown

• Total value: $15,000,000
• Term: 4 years
• Cap hit: $3,750,000 per season (per Puckpedia cap tracking database)
• Previous deal: 2 years, $5,000,000 ($2.5M AAV) signed July 1, 2024 (CapWages salary database)

Comparisons to Other Goalies

The table below places Stolarz’s cap hit in context among NHL goaltenders signed in 2024.

The implication: Stolarz’s AAV ranks 38th among NHL goaltenders in 2025-26, according to Puckpedia. It’s a below-average salary for a starter but above the typical backup rate — reflecting his hybrid role.

Is Stolarz a Good Goalie?

2024-25 Stats and Performance

• Record: 21-8-3
• Save percentage: .926
• Goals-against average: 2.14 (NHL.com)

Those numbers placed him among the top five goaltenders in the league for SV% (among those with at least 20 starts). RotoWire highlighted that his .926 SV% was a career high and nearly 20 points above the league average of .907.

Career Averages and Trends

League average SV% (2024-25): .907 · Stolarz advantage: +19 points

The catch: his career high in games played is just 34, leaving questions about whether he can sustain elite numbers over a full starter’s workload.

Strengths and Weaknesses

• Strength: Size (6’6″, 243 lbs) covers net efficiently, especially low shots.
• Strength: Calm demeanor in pressure situations, praised by InGoal Magazine.
• Weakness: Injury history – missed significant time in 2025-26 due to groin.
• Weakness: Limited sample as a true starter; career high 34 games in 2024-25.

Should the Maple Leafs Carry Three Goalies When Stolarz Returns?

Current Goalie Depth: Woll, Stolarz, Hildebeast?

Toronto’s goaltending roster includes Stolarz (injured), Joseph Woll ($3.1M cap hit), and prospects such as Dennis Hildeby. ESPN shows Stolarz and Woll as the only goaltenders with active contracts.

Roster and Cap Implications

• Both Stolarz ($3.75M) and Woll ($3.1M) are under contract through at least 2026-27.
• Carrying three goalies would require a roster spot, likely sending a forward to the AHL.
• Waiver eligibility: Hildeby is waiver-exempt; Woll and Stolarz are not.

Analyst Opinions

Sportsnet analyst Elliotte Friedman suggested the Leafs could explore a three-goalie rotation to ease Stolarz back. “They’ve invested in both, and they’re not going to waive either,” Friedman said in an April 2026 segment.

Historical Precedents

Several teams have carried three goalies for short stretches — the 2021 Tampa Bay Lightning used a third goalie during a cap crunch. For Toronto, the risk is losing a depth forward or exposing a goalie to waivers. No clear consensus exists.

Anthony Stolarz Career Timeline

• January 20, 1994: Born in Edison, New Jersey
• 2012 NHL Entry Draft: Selected 45th overall by the New Jersey Devils
• 2014-15: NHL debut with Philadelphia Flyers
• 2016-17: Traded to Edmonton Oilers
• June 2024: Won Stanley Cup with Edmonton Oilers as backup (NHL.com)
• July 2024: Signed 4-year, $15M contract with Toronto Maple Leafs (NHL.com)
• 2024-25 season: Career-high 34 games, 21-8-3 record, .926 SV%
• March 2025: Groin injury, missed remainder of season (ESPN)
• 2025-26: Extension negotiations and injury recovery continue (The Hockey News)

What We Know — And What Remains Uncertain

“Stolarz has given us a chance to win every night. His size and calm are rare. We’re careful with his recovery because he’s a big part of our plans.”

— Craig Berube, Maple Leafs head coach, via Sportsnet

“When Stolarz is healthy, Toronto has a legitimate 1A/1B situation. The question is whether he can stay healthy enough to make that work.”

— Elliotte Friedman, NHL analyst, via Sportsnet

Stolarz’s trajectory — from a sixth-round draft project to a Stanley Cup winner and a $15-million man — shows how far a big frame and steady nerves can take a goaltender. For the Maple Leafs, the decision is stark: trust Stolarz as a starter once he returns, or hedge with a three-goalie rotation and risk disrupting team chemistry. The answer will determine whether Toronto’s crease becomes a strength or a lingering question mark.

For a deeper look at the incident and his contract situation, see Anthony Stolarzs injury and contract details.

Frequently asked questions

Related reading: Jamie Benn – Collapsed Lung Surgery · London Knights Playoff Schedule 2026